Ichiro, a sure-fire Hall of Famer, but unanimous? Is he truly on Mariano's level? His late start in MLB makes his 3000+ hits even more remarkable, but does it overshadow a somewhat less impactful second half of his career? Let the debate begin!
Beyond Ichiro, this year's ballot presents some fascinating dilemmas. Is a shorter peak, like Dustin Pedroia's, enough for Cooperstown, even with MVP and multiple rings? How do we weigh accolades versus longevity?
Rollins' impressive all-around numbers make a compelling case. Is he an overlooked candidate? Where does he rank among the great shortstops of his era?
And what about CC Sabathia? A workhorse, a leader, but an ERA over 3.70. Does his win total and strikeout count outweigh a seemingly inflated ERA in a hitter-friendly park and era? Is he the last of a dying breed, the true ace who ate innings?
Let’s hear your thoughts on these candidates and any others on your ballot. Who gets your vote and why? This is a Hall of Fame class with some real discussion points.
Ichiro, a sure-fire Hall of Famer, but unanimous? Is he truly on Mariano's level? His late start in MLB makes his 3000+ hits even more remarkable, but does it overshadow a somewhat less impactful second half of his career? Let the debate begin!
Beyond Ichiro, this year's ballot presents some fascinating dilemmas. Is a shorter peak, like Dustin Pedroia's, enough for Cooperstown, even with MVP and multiple rings? How do we weigh accolades versus longevity?
Rollins' impressive all-around numbers make a compelling case. Is he an overlooked candidate? Where does he rank among the great shortstops of his era?
And what about CC Sabathia? A workhorse, a leader, but an ERA over 3.70. Does his win total and strikeout count outweigh a seemingly inflated ERA in a hitter-friendly park and era? Is he the last of a dying breed, the true ace who ate innings?
Let’s hear your thoughts on these candidates and any others on your ballot. Who gets your vote and why? This is a Hall of Fame class with some real discussion points.
- By Anonymous