Braves Offseason Grades: Did They Do Enough to Compete in 2025? 

As we gear up for the 2025 MLB season, the Atlanta Braves have left fans buzzing with mixed feelings about their offseason moves. With Opening Day just around the corner, it's time to dive into the hot topics surrounding the team.

First off, how would you grade the Braves' offseason? Many analysts are leaning towards a C or D, citing the lack of impactful signings and the departure of key players. Jurickson Profar is a solid addition, but does he really fill the gaps left by the likes of Jorge Soler and Joe Jimenez? With the Mets and Phillies making significant upgrades, did the Braves miss an opportunity to bolster their roster?

Speaking of roster dynamics, what are your expectations for Ronald Acuña Jr. and Spencer Strider as they return from injuries? Acuña's previous recovery from an ACL tear was rocky, but this time around, do you think he’ll hit the ground running? Or will he need time to regain his confidence? On the other hand, Strider has shown promise in spring training, but can we expect him to return to form quickly, or will he face challenges in regaining his command?

And let’s not forget about Sean Murphy. With another injury setback, should we be worried about his long-term viability as the starting catcher? Is he at risk of becoming a backup as Drake Baldwin pushes for playing time?

Let’s hear your thoughts! What are your bold predictions for the Braves this season? Will they rise to the challenge in a competitive NL East, or are we in for a disappointing year? Share your insights, experiences, and any hot takes you have!

Great questions—this Braves offseason has definitely stirred up a mix of cautious optimism and straight-up skepticism.

If I had to give a grade for the Braves’ offseason, I’d probably land somewhere around a C+. They didn’t blow us away with blockbuster signings, and losing players like Jorge Soler and Joe Jimenez does sting—especially since the division rivals went big. Jurickson Profar is a fine utility player, but let’s be honest: he’s not the kind of move that screams "we’re going for it all." So yeah, it feels like the Braves were playing it safe while others loaded up.

Now, Ronald Acuña Jr. is always the big X-factor. Coming back from injury again, it’s fair to wonder how long it’ll take for him to find his groove. But if there’s one guy who’s got the talent and fire to bounce back fast, it’s Ronnie. I’m cautiously optimistic—expecting a slightly slower start but a major second-half surge.

As for Spencer Strider, man, if his spring is any indication, he’s ready to remind everyone why he was once seen as a future ace. But command is the key, and he’s gotta prove he can stay consistent over a full season. If he does? Watch out.

Sean Murphy’s situation is tricky. The talent’s there, but durability is starting to become a concern. If Baldwin keeps the momentum going and Murphy’s bat stays quiet or his health falters, the Braves might not have much choice but to shift the balance behind the plate. I wouldn't be surprised if we see more of a timeshare this year than a clear-cut starter.

Bold prediction? The Braves finish with 92 wins, clinch a Wild Card spot, and ride a breakout season from someone unexpected—maybe a guy like AJ Smith-Shawver or even Vaughn Grissom making a big impact mid-season. Oh, and Acuña? He’ll still find a way to go 30/30, because that’s just who he is.

How about you? Are you more optimistic about the Braves' moves, or do you think they played it too safe this winter?