Keep or Cut: The Catcher Dilemma for 2025 - Who's Worth Holding Onto?
Posted: Sat Nov 23, 2024 12:12 am
As we dive into the offseason, the debate around keep or cut decisions is heating up, especially for catchers. Let's take a closer look at some intriguing cases: Austin Wells, Logan O'Hoppe, Ryan Jeffers, and David Fry. Each of these players presents a unique set of circumstances that could sway your decision-making.
Austin Wells has shown promise, especially in the second half of 2023, with a solid wRC+ and a potential increase in playing time. Is he a keeper at $5 or less, or do you think his early struggles are a sign of things to come?
Logan O'Hoppe's rollercoaster season raises questions about his consistency. With injury concerns and fluctuating performance, is he worth the risk at $8-$10? Or do you think his upside justifies the price?
Ryan Jeffers had a decent year, but with competition for playing time increasing, is he a player you’d be willing to cut loose? What factors do you consider when deciding on a catcher who might not be a full-time starter?
Lastly, David Fry's situation is complicated by his upcoming elbow surgery. If you stash him, are you banking on a late-season return, or is the risk too high given his uncertain role post-recovery?
Let’s hear your thoughts! Which catchers are you keeping, cutting, or trading? What strategies do you employ when evaluating players with such mixed signals? Share your insights and let’s spark a lively discussion!
Austin Wells has shown promise, especially in the second half of 2023, with a solid wRC+ and a potential increase in playing time. Is he a keeper at $5 or less, or do you think his early struggles are a sign of things to come?
Logan O'Hoppe's rollercoaster season raises questions about his consistency. With injury concerns and fluctuating performance, is he worth the risk at $8-$10? Or do you think his upside justifies the price?
Ryan Jeffers had a decent year, but with competition for playing time increasing, is he a player you’d be willing to cut loose? What factors do you consider when deciding on a catcher who might not be a full-time starter?
Lastly, David Fry's situation is complicated by his upcoming elbow surgery. If you stash him, are you banking on a late-season return, or is the risk too high given his uncertain role post-recovery?
Let’s hear your thoughts! Which catchers are you keeping, cutting, or trading? What strategies do you employ when evaluating players with such mixed signals? Share your insights and let’s spark a lively discussion!