- Sat Jan 18, 2025 6:41 pm
#4228
Ryan Helsley's future in St. Louis: Extension or Trade?
Ryan Helsley’s comments about a lack of extension talks with the Cardinals have ignited speculation. Is this a sign of an impending trade, or simply posturing? Helsley’s dominant 2024 season makes him a valuable asset, but his upcoming free agency complicates matters.
The Cardinals face a tough decision: contend now with Helsley at a high cost, or trade him for future pieces? His potential salary demands, comparable to Diaz and Hader, seem at odds with the Cardinals’ stated goal of payroll reduction.
What's the best move for the Cardinals? Trade him now for maximum value, hold and hope for a contending season justifying a hefty extension, or risk losing him for nothing in free agency?
This situation raises broader questions about valuing closers. Their volatile nature makes long-term investments risky. Is a Helsley-level closer worth the financial commitment, or are those resources better spent elsewhere?
Weigh in with your thoughts. Is Helsley worth the price? What should the Cardinals do? What does this say about the current market for elite closers?
Ryan Helsley’s comments about a lack of extension talks with the Cardinals have ignited speculation. Is this a sign of an impending trade, or simply posturing? Helsley’s dominant 2024 season makes him a valuable asset, but his upcoming free agency complicates matters.
The Cardinals face a tough decision: contend now with Helsley at a high cost, or trade him for future pieces? His potential salary demands, comparable to Diaz and Hader, seem at odds with the Cardinals’ stated goal of payroll reduction.
What's the best move for the Cardinals? Trade him now for maximum value, hold and hope for a contending season justifying a hefty extension, or risk losing him for nothing in free agency?
This situation raises broader questions about valuing closers. Their volatile nature makes long-term investments risky. Is a Helsley-level closer worth the financial commitment, or are those resources better spent elsewhere?
Weigh in with your thoughts. Is Helsley worth the price? What should the Cardinals do? What does this say about the current market for elite closers?