Cardinals Conundrum: Should They Trade a Starter or Stick with the Status Quo? 

The St. Louis Cardinals are at a crossroads this offseason, and the decisions they make could define their trajectory for years to come. With Nolan Arenado likely to remain in St. Louis, the focus shifts to their pitching staff and the potential for a youth movement. Should they trade veteran starters like Erick Fedde or Steven Matz to make room for promising young arms, or is it wiser to hold onto their experience in hopes of contending in a relatively weak NL Central?

Let’s dive into the debate. On one hand, trading a starter could yield valuable prospects and open up opportunities for young pitchers like Tink Hence and Michael McGreevy, who are knocking on the door of the majors. On the other hand, with the Cardinals coming off an 83-win season, is it really the right time to pivot towards a full rebuild? Could a healthy season from veterans and some luck put them back in the playoff picture?

What do you think? Should the Cardinals embrace a youth movement and trade from their rotation, or should they hold steady and aim for a competitive season? And if they do trade a starter, who should be the first to go? Let’s hear your thoughts and bold predictions for the Cardinals’ future!