Is Paul Goldschmidt the Yankees' Biggest Mistake of 2025? Join the Debate! 

The New York Yankees have made a controversial move by signing Paul Goldschmidt, a player whose performance has been on a downward trajectory. At 37 years old, Goldschmidt's recent stats raise eyebrows, especially when considering his significant drop in batting average and alarming increase in strikeouts. With his OPS+ plummeting and a concerning rise in ground into double plays, many fans are left wondering: is this really the best the Yankees could do?

This decision has sparked a debate among fans and analysts alike. Some argue that Goldschmidt could still provide veteran leadership and occasional power, while others see him as a stopgap that could hinder the development of younger talent like Cody Bellinger or prospect Ben Rice.

What do you think? Is Goldschmidt a wise addition to the Yankees, or is this a misstep that could cost them in the long run? Could the Yankees have made a better choice, or is this part of a larger strategy to position themselves for a future star like Vladimir Guerrero Jr.?

Let’s hear your thoughts! What are your bold predictions for Goldschmidt's performance this season? Will he defy the odds and prove the doubters wrong, or is this the beginning of a steep decline? Share your insights and let’s get the conversation rolling!