Rookie Sensation: Can Tobias Myers Build on His Breakout Season? 

Tobias Myers has certainly made a name for himself in his rookie season with the Milwaukee Brewers, but how sustainable is his success moving forward? With a 3.00 ERA and a solid record, he’s shown flashes of brilliance, yet his underlying stats tell a different story. His FIP and xERA suggest that he might not be the shutdown pitcher that his surface numbers imply.

This brings up some intriguing questions for us as fans and analysts. Do you think Myers can maintain his performance in 2025, or will the league catch up to him? Given that he’s still pre-arbitration at 26, could he be a hidden gem for the Brewers, or is he more of a flash in the pan?

Moreover, with Freddy Peralta and Brandon Woodruff leading the rotation, how do you see Myers fitting into the long-term plans for the pitching staff? Will he be a reliable third option, or do you think the Brewers should look for external upgrades to bolster their rotation?

Let’s also consider the broader implications of his performance. If Myers continues to develop, could he become a key player in a potential playoff run? Or should we temper our expectations based on those concerning underlying metrics?

I’m eager to hear your thoughts! What are your bold predictions for Myers in 2025? How do you feel about the Brewers' pitching depth overall? Let’s dive into this discussion!