Uncovering the Legacy of John Donaldson: The Greatest Pitcher You've Never Heard Of 

As we gear up for the 2025 Classic Baseball Era Committee ballot, one name stands out that has sparked both admiration and debate: John Donaldson. With staggering career totals that include 428 wins and 5,295 strikeouts, Donaldson's legacy in Black baseball is nothing short of remarkable. Yet, his achievements often come with a caveat—much of his career was spent outside the major leagues, leading to questions about the validity of his statistics and comparisons to contemporaries like Satchel Paige.

This brings us to a pivotal discussion: How do we evaluate the greatness of players like Donaldson who thrived in the shadows of the major leagues? Are their contributions to the game undervalued simply because they played in a segregated era?

Moreover, with the upcoming vote on December 8, do you think Donaldson deserves a spot in the Hall of Fame? What criteria should we use to assess players from the Negro Leagues, especially when their records are often incomplete or disputed?

Let’s also consider the impact of players like Donaldson on the game today. How do you think the legacy of Black baseball players from the early 20th century influences current discussions about diversity and representation in Major League Baseball?

Share your thoughts, bold predictions, and personal insights. Do you believe that recognizing players like John Donaldson is crucial for a complete understanding of baseball history? Or do you think the focus should remain on those who played in the major leagues? Let’s dive into this rich history and explore the complexities of baseball's past!