- Fri Feb 28, 2025 6:30 pm
#7145
Dave Roberts recently expressed his frustration over being overlooked for the 2024 NL Manager of the Year award, despite leading the Dodgers to the best record in baseball amidst a slew of injuries. This raises some interesting questions about how we evaluate managerial success in baseball.
Is it fair to judge a manager solely based on awards, or should we consider the context of their achievements? Roberts has consistently demonstrated his ability to navigate challenges and maximize the talent on his roster, yet he finished seventh in the voting. Does this indicate a bias against teams with high expectations, or is it a reflection of how we perceive success in the sport?
Moreover, with the Dodgers boasting a roster filled with superstars like Shohei Ohtani and Freddie Freeman, does this overshadow the managerial decisions that contribute to their success? Are we taking for granted the strategic moves that Roberts makes behind the scenes?
As fans, how do we balance our admiration for individual player performances with the recognition of a manager's role in orchestrating a winning team?
Let’s dive into this debate. Do you think Roberts deserves more recognition for his contributions? How do you feel about the criteria used for managerial awards? And what bold predictions do you have for the Dodgers this season? Share your thoughts!
Is it fair to judge a manager solely based on awards, or should we consider the context of their achievements? Roberts has consistently demonstrated his ability to navigate challenges and maximize the talent on his roster, yet he finished seventh in the voting. Does this indicate a bias against teams with high expectations, or is it a reflection of how we perceive success in the sport?
Moreover, with the Dodgers boasting a roster filled with superstars like Shohei Ohtani and Freddie Freeman, does this overshadow the managerial decisions that contribute to their success? Are we taking for granted the strategic moves that Roberts makes behind the scenes?
As fans, how do we balance our admiration for individual player performances with the recognition of a manager's role in orchestrating a winning team?
Let’s dive into this debate. Do you think Roberts deserves more recognition for his contributions? How do you feel about the criteria used for managerial awards? And what bold predictions do you have for the Dodgers this season? Share your thoughts!