Old Arms, New Woes: Are Aging Pitchers a Risky Draft Gamble? 

As we dive deeper into the 2025 season, the news surrounding veteran pitchers Max Scherzer and Yu Darvish is raising eyebrows and sparking debates among fantasy baseball enthusiasts. Scherzer, now 40, is experiencing thumb pain during spring training, while Darvish, at 38, is showing signs of fatigue after limited innings. This brings up a critical question for all of us: how do we approach drafting older pitchers in our fantasy leagues?

Historically, we’ve seen some legends defy age, but the reality is that injuries can derail even the most seasoned veterans. Are we witnessing the beginning of the end for these two future Hall of Famers? Or could they still provide value if managed correctly?

Let’s talk strategy. Are you willing to take a risk on aging pitchers like Scherzer and Darvish, or do you prefer to invest in younger arms with less wear and tear? What’s your threshold for drafting older players?

Additionally, with the rise of younger talent in the league, is it time to shift our focus away from established stars and embrace the new wave of pitchers?

I’d love to hear your thoughts on this! Share your experiences with drafting older pitchers in the past—did it pay off or leave you regretting your decision? And what bold predictions do you have for Scherzer and Darvish this season? Let’s get the conversation rolling!