Eury Perez's Comeback: Will He Save the Marlins' Season? 

The Miami Marlins are in an interesting position as they gear up for the 2025 season. With Eury Pérez targeting a return around the All-Star break after his Tommy John surgery, the question arises: how will his comeback impact the Marlins' rotation and their overall strategy for the season?

Pérez was once hailed as one of the top pitching prospects in baseball, and his performance prior to the injury showcased his potential. However, with the Marlins not expected to compete this year, should they take a cautious approach with his return? Or could they benefit from integrating him back into the lineup sooner, especially if they find themselves in a position to trade some of their other pitchers like Sandy Alcántara or Ryan Weathers?

Moreover, Andrew Nardi's health adds another layer of complexity. If he can bounce back from his offseason issues, could he also become a valuable trade asset? The Marlins have a history of trading controllable players, and with their current trajectory, it seems likely they might look to capitalize on any value they can get.

What are your thoughts on the Marlins' strategy moving forward? Should they prioritize developing their young talent like Pérez and Nardi, or should they focus on making trades to build for the future? And how do you see the dynamics of their pitching rotation evolving as the season progresses? Let's discuss!

The Marlins are definitely walking a fine line between cautious optimism and strategic planning this season—especially when it comes to Eury Pérez and the rest of their pitching staff.

Eury Pérez’s return around the All-Star break is one of the most anticipated moments of the season for Miami fans. Given his electric stuff and elite prospect pedigree, there’s no doubt he could become the ace of this rotation in the near future. But with the Marlins unlikely to contend this year, I think a measured and cautious approach is the wisest move. There’s no need to rush him back just to try and squeeze out a few extra wins in a rebuilding season. If he finishes the year strong and healthy—even if it’s with an innings limit—that’s a win in itself.

That said, his return could have ripple effects. If Pérez looks sharp in rehab and starts dominating late in the season, it could give the front office the green light to explore trades involving veterans like Sandy Alcántara (depending on his own recovery from Tommy John) or Ryan Weathers. The Marlins have shown they’re not shy about dealing from their strengths—especially when it comes to pitching.

Andrew Nardi is another interesting piece in all this. If he regains his form, he could absolutely become a trade chip, especially with the value placed on lefty relievers at the deadline. But I could also see the Marlins holding onto him a bit longer if they believe he can anchor the bullpen during the next competitive window.

In terms of strategy, developing young arms like Pérez and Nardi should absolutely be the priority—but there’s nothing wrong with keeping an eye on maximizing value through trades. The key is balance: letting the young core grow while still being opportunistic when other teams come calling.

As for rotation dynamics? I expect a bit of a revolving door early in the year, with the Marlins trying out different combinations, but once Pérez is back and if Alcántara makes his return later in the season, fans could get a glimpse of what the future holds. And it’s a pretty exciting future if managed correctly.

What’s your take—would you rather see the Marlins stay patient and build through youth, or push for more aggressive trades now to speed things up?

The Marlins are definitely walking a fine line between cautious optimism and strategic planning this season—especially when it comes to Eury Pérez and the rest of their pitching staff.

Eury Pérez’s return around the All-Star break is one of the most anticipated moments of the season for Miami fans. Given his electric stuff and elite prospect pedigree, there’s no doubt he could become the ace of this rotation in the near future. But with the Marlins unlikely to contend this year, I think a measured and cautious approach is the wisest move. There’s no need to rush him back just to try and squeeze out a few extra wins in a rebuilding season. If he finishes the year strong and healthy—even if it’s with an innings limit—that’s a win in itself.

That said, his return could have ripple effects. If Pérez looks sharp in rehab and starts dominating late in the season, it could give the front office the green light to explore trades involving veterans like Sandy Alcántara (depending on his own recovery from Tommy John) or Ryan Weathers. The Marlins have shown they’re not shy about dealing from their strengths—especially when it comes to pitching.

Andrew Nardi is another interesting piece in all this. If he regains his form, he could absolutely become a trade chip, especially with the value placed on lefty relievers at the deadline. But I could also see the Marlins holding onto him a bit longer if they believe he can anchor the bullpen during the next competitive window.

In terms of strategy, developing young arms like Pérez and Nardi should absolutely be the priority—but there’s nothing wrong with keeping an eye on maximizing value through trades. The key is balance: letting the young core grow while still being opportunistic when other teams come calling.

As for rotation dynamics? I expect a bit of a revolving door early in the year, with the Marlins trying out different combinations, but once Pérez is back and if Alcántara makes his return later in the season, fans could get a glimpse of what the future holds. And it’s a pretty exciting future if managed correctly.

What’s your take—would you rather see the Marlins stay patient and build through youth, or push for more aggressive trades now to speed things up?